Could Your Child Be Found Partly Responsible for an Accident? A Guide to Contributory Negligence
Share this article
As August progresses, families across Scotland are preparing for the return to school. Busier roads, increased traffic and children walking or cycling to class can all contribute to a higher risk of accidents.
But while motorists have a duty to take extra care, children can be impulsive and might not always recognise potential dangers in the same way as adults.
At Gildeas Solicitors, we help families understand their legal rights following an accident.
Read on as we explain how the law approaches children and contributory negligence if the unexpected happens as the schools go back this August.
What is contributory negligence?
Contributory negligence is a legal term used when an injured person is found to have been partly responsible for an accident.
If this applies, any compensation they receive might be reduced to reflect their share of the responsibility. For example, if the accident was 50/50 on either side.
If a child is injured in an accident, one of the legal issues that may arise is contributory negligence. Unlike adults, children aren’t judged by the same standard when considering contributory negligence, as their age, maturity and understanding of risk are all considered.
When would contributory negligence apply?
Every case is different, and the court will consider all of the circumstances before deciding if contributory negligence applies. It’s also up to the person defending the claim to prove that the injured person was partly at fault.
Some examples of situations where children could be found contributorily negligent:
- Running into or playing in the road,
- Child car seats and booster cushions being used improperly,
- Cycling or using scooters without reasonable care,
- Ignoring crossings or traffic signals
It’s important to remember these are only examples. Whether contributory negligence applies will always depend on the child’s age, level of maturity and the circumstances of the accident. A young child is not expected to show the same judgement or awareness of danger as an adult.
In many cases, drivers are still expected to take extra care around children – especially near schools, parks, or known walking routes.
Failing to adjust speed or attention in these areas can result in the driver being found liable.
What does it mean if my child is contributorily negligent?
If a court decides a child was partly responsible for an accident, it doesn’t automatically prevent them from making a personal injury claim. Instead, any compensation awarded might be reduced to reflect their share of the responsibility.
The amount of any reduction will depend on the circumstances of the case, including the child’s age, maturity and ability to recognise danger.
A good example is the case of Jackson v Murray [2015]. A 13-year-old girl was seriously injured after running across the road from behind her school bus and into the path of an approaching car.
Although the driver argued that the child was mostly responsible, the Supreme Court recognised that children can’t always judge speed and distance in the same way as adults.
It ultimately decided that both the driver and the child shared equal responsibility for the accident, meaning her compensation was reduced by 50%, rather than the much larger reduction suggested earlier in the case.
This decision highlighted that, when considering children and contributory negligence, the courts will carefully balance a child’s actions against the responsibility of drivers to anticipate and respond to foreseeable risks.
Tips for parents to avoid back to school accidents
Even if you’re driving, your child is likely walking some of the way – whether that’s through the school car park or across a busy street to reach the football fields.
It’s worth having a quick conversation with them about staying visible and alert, especially during early mornings and evening pickups.
Some tips to share with them include:
- Wearing high-vis or reflective items, like jackets or a bag cover,
- Crossing at designated areas, even if it takes slightly longer,
- Making eye contact with drivers before stepping into the road,
- Avoiding distractions like phones or headphones near traffic
Many schools and clubs already promote road safety, but reinforcing at home can make a big difference.
Children and contributory negligence explained
As children head back to school this August, road safety should be a priority for everyone.
While the law recognises that children don’t always have the same awareness or judgement as adults, there are circumstances where contributory negligence may affect the amount of compensation awarded after an accident.
If your child has been injured and you’re unsure about your legal rights, it’s important to seek specialist advice as soon as possible.
At Gildeas Solicitors, our experienced personal injury solicitors can assess the circumstances of your case, explain whether children and contributory negligence may be relevant, and guide you through the claims process.
If you’d like to discuss your child’s accident, get in touch with our team today for expert advice.
Claim smarter.
Access our free how-to guide on making a personal injury claim.
Jargon free and designed for you.
Gildeas Solicitors is a recognised law firm specialising in personal injury claims, supporting you throughout Scotland from our offices in Glasgow and Edinburgh. We’re passionate about what we do, whilst putting our clients’ interests first. That’s why we make personal injury personal.
Considering our services? Call our dedicated team today on 0141 331 6070.
More to explore
Scotland's Claim Culture? The Truth Behind False Claims
Share this article
If you’ve ever heard someone say, “Everyone’s claiming compensation these days,” you’re not alone.
The phrase “compensation culture” has been around for years. It’s often used to suggest that people are making personal injury claims for easy money or looking for someone to blame whenever an accident happens.
But is that really what’s happening in Scotland?
Read on as we discuss the facts behind personal injury claims and why genuine claimants shouldn’t be put off.
The Personal Injury Landscape Is Changing
While the number of personal injury claims across the UK has fallen over recent years, claims themselves are becoming more complex. Recent UK government data showed that motor accident claims were down to 300, 867 from 2025/2026 – less than half recorded of the 770, 791 recorded in the 10 years previous from 2015/2016.
Today’s personal injury claims can often involve multiple injuries, digital evidence, and increasingly complex medical questions resulting in detailed investigations – rather than the more straightforward claims we may have seen in the past.
Technology has fundamentally changed the way claims are handled. Clients are using AI tools such as ChatGPT to research, get legal advice and in some cases even help with representing themselves in court.
Online habits have changed who we seek advice from too. People now overwhelmingly post on TikTok, Instagram, or Facebook to share their experiences and give others advice, meaning greater trust is placed in content creators.
This has given clients more access to legal information than they’ve ever had, leaving them more empowered and confident – but it can also create confusion, and even a sense of distrust within the client/solicitor relationship.
Not everything shared on social media or online forums reflects how Scottish law actually works in practice – and there are even cases where AI usage has caused a claim to be thrown out of UK courts such as in the case of Your Home Partners.
In addition, CCTV footage, dashcams, mobile phones, smart watches and other digital records have all become valuable pieces of evidence when establishing what happened in an accident.
Every case is different, which is why tailored legal advice from an experienced personal injury solicitor remains the best option in taking your case forward.
Does Scotland Really Have a Compensation Culture?
The idea of a compensation culture has been debated for decades. Newspaper headlines and stories about fraudulent claims have helped create the impression that people are constantly taking legal action over minor accidents.
At Gildeas Solicitors, we’ve seen first-hand how these misconceptions can prevent injured people from getting the compensation they need to rebuild their lives.
While fraudulent claims do happen, they’re a very small part of the wider picture.
The reality is very different.
Genuine personal injury claims exist to help people recover after they’ve been injured because someone else failed in their duty of care.
Further, Scotland’s legal system has strict safeguards in place to identify false claims:
- The courts require evidence
- Insurers investigate cases thoroughly
- Medical experts have to properly assess injuries
- Solicitors must also follow strict professional standards before pursuing a claim
So if your injury wasn’t caused by someone else’s negligence, your claim isn’t likely to succeed.
Why Genuine People Still Don’t Make Personal Injury Claims
Ironically, the biggest problem isn’t too many false claims. It’s that lots of people who have the right to claim decide not to.
Some think they’ll be seen as trying to make money from an accident, whilst others assume the process will be too much hassle, too expensive, or they’re unlikely to succeed.
These concerns often leave injured people paying for treatment themselves, losing earnings while off work or struggling financially after an accident that was never their fault in the first place.
Ultimately, making a personal injury claim isn’t about taking advantage. The system is simply there to help you recover from the impact of an injury caused by another person’s negligence.
Why Myths Can Be Harmful
The phrase “claim culture” can make it seem as though anyone making a claim is doing something inherently wrong.
That simply isn’t true.
If you’ve suffered an injury because another person, employer, road user or organisation failed to keep you safe – making a claim is part of the standard legal process designed to put you back, as far as possible, in the position you would’ve been in before the accident.
That compensation can help cover lost earnings, medical treatment, rehabilitation, travel costs and the wider impact your injury has had on your daily life.
Without it, injured people face unnecessary financial pressure alongside their recovery.
Why Choosing the Right Solicitor Matters
As personal injury claims become more complex, having experienced legal representation is increasingly valuable.
An experienced solicitor knows what evidence is needed, understands the Scottish court system and can deal with insurers on your behalf. They can also explain the process in plain English, helping you understand your options from the beginning.
Good legal advice isn’t about encouraging people to make claims unnecessarily.
We’re here for those with genuine cases – to secure the compensation they’re entitled to, while ensuring every claim is supported by the right evidence.
Don’t Let the Claim Culture Myth Stop You
The phrase “claim culture” makes for attention grabbing headlines, but it doesn’t reflect the experience of genuine injured people across Scotland.
If you’ve been injured because of someone else’s negligence, you shouldn’t let myths or public opinion prevent you from understanding your legal rights.
At Gildeas Solicitors, we understand that making a personal injury claim might feel like a heavy decision. That’s why we’re here to provide clear advice based on your personal circumstances.
We’ll explain whether you have a claim, guide you through every stage of the process, and work to secure the compensation you deserve.
Claim smarter.
Access our free how-to guide on making a personal injury claim.
Jargon free and designed for you.
Gildeas Solicitors is a recognised law firm specialising in personal injury claims, supporting you throughout Scotland from our offices in Glasgow and Edinburgh. We’re passionate about what we do, whilst putting our clients’ interests first. That’s why we make personal injury personal.
Considering our services? Call our dedicated team today on 0141 331 6070.